ID cards will give ‘false’ data

Sarah Spiller writes on the BBC web site:

The government’s ID card system will give thousands of “false matches” when more than six million people are registered on its database, an academic has claimed.

Biometric data holding a person’s unique physiological characteristics will be stored on a microchip in the cards.

But Professor John Daugman, said using fingerprints as a key biometric measure will cause major problems.

Professor Daugman’s conclusion:

“For the scheme as a whole it means that it can no longer deliver the goal of one citizen, one identity, because it cannot survive so many comparisons without making false matches – so there will be false claims of multiple identities.

“It could still be useful for other purposes but I think it would have failed for reasons that are probably to date, predictable.”

His comments are taken from a BBC Radio 4 “File on Four” programme first broadcast at 2000 BST on Tuesday 31 July, repeated 1700 BST on Sunday 5 August. The programme MP3 can also be downloaded here until Tuesday 7th August. A transcript should be available in due course via the programmes web page.

2 Responses to “ID cards will give ‘false’ data”

  1. Colin Simpson Says:

    Correct me if I’m wrong but what Professor Daugman seems to be implying is that there will be no need to forge these ID Cards since you’ll be able to get ‘Proper’ multiple identities from the IPS.

  2. ID in the News» Blog Archive » ‘False matches’ Says:

    [...] 8216;False matches’ The Home Office has responded to John Daugman’s warning that a deluge of false fingerprint matches would scupper the ID card scheme. The BBC tacked thi [...]

Search provided by Google